The Gun as Talisman Fallacy

Your gun does not protect you just by virtue of you owning or carrying it.

by posted on February 17, 2022
Handgun Amidst Shells

Learning how to shoot and taking responsibility for your personal safety by carrying a concealed firearm is empowering. It’s so empowering, in fact, that if you don’t have the right mindset, it can actually cause you to fall into a dangerous mental quirk: the “gun as talisman” fallacy.

A talisman, sometimes called an amulet, is an object believed to ward off evil and bring good fortune, typically by magic or mysticism. Some cultures (ancient and current) and religions place a lot of emphasis on talismans. They’re like souped-up good luck charms.

If you have an object you think is lucky or protective, no problem. But let me be clear: Your gun is not it. Your gun does not protect you just by virtue of you owning or carrying it. If you have a vague, maybe even subconscious sense that somehow it does, you’ve fallen into the gun as talisman fallacy. What’s wrong with that?

A concealed carrier who views her gun as a talisman runs the risk of becoming overconfident. It’s far too easy for her to think, “I’ve got a gun; I’ll be safe,” and walk right into a potentially dangerous situation that she’d be better off avoiding. If you wouldn’t do something unarmed, but you’re willing to do it while you’re carrying, you might have fallen into gun-as-talisman thinking. Stop and think for a second. If you’d go to a particular place only if you’re armed, but never consider it without your gun, there’s a good chance you shouldn’t be going there at all—armed or not.

Your gun does not increase your level of personal safety just by existing, and thinking that it does can lead you to do some just plain dumb stuff or get yourself into stupid situations you should have avoided. If anything, you should be more mindful of where you go and what you do when you’re carrying for the opposite reason—that whole “With great power comes great responsibility” thing. What does increase your level of personal safety?

Your gun, combined with the ability to use it, the willingness to use it, the wisdom to avoid having to use it if possible, and perhaps most importantly, the mindset and situational awareness to avoid situations where it might be needed in the first place—those things keep you safe. It’s worth noting that not only is a gun not a magical object that protects you—it’s a last-resort measure when all other self-defense options have failed or were never on the table to begin with. It's far better to use common sense and awareness to keep yourself out of any situation where you might wish you had a magical talisman.

This isn’t to say that a gun is never the answer—obviously, sometimes it is. And it’s not to say that you have to be John Wick in order to use one effectively—countless tales of defensive gun uses have proven that false. However, you should be sufficiently trained and practice with your firearm.

But remember: A gun is not a talisman that magically keeps you safe just by virtue of its existence. Rather, it’s a tool that, when combined with other tools in your self-defense toolkit, can increase your personal safety in unavoidable situations.  

Latest

Yackley Women Only Shooting Event Lede 2
Yackley Women Only Shooting Event Lede 2

Why Every Woman Should Attend a Women-Only Shooting Event

Whether it’s holding a baby or holding a gun, there are some things that women are naturally going to find easier to understand when demonstrated by another woman.

Champion Shooter Jessie Harrison Returns to Team Taurus

Harrison is recognized globally as one of the most accomplished and respected shooters in the world.

New Guns 2025: Mossberg 990 Aftershock

The 990 Aftershock is a 12-gauge, 3” semi-automatic version of Mossberg's 590 Shockwave tactical firearm introduced in 2017.

2024 Olympic Medalist Sagen Maddalena Tops Podium at ISSF Lima World Cup

This Lima World Cup marks Maddalena’s first international competition since she medaled at the Paris 2024 Olympic Games in Women’s 50m Rifle 3 positions.

Team Beretta’s Desirae Edmunds Inducted into NSCA Hall of Fame

This prestigious honor recognizes Desirae’s outstanding career, dedication to the sport, and the lasting impact she’s had on the clay target community.

Women’s Podium Sweep at 2025 ISSF World Cup in Lima

In addition to Kimberly Rhode, Samantha Simonton and Dania Vizzi's medals, Christian Elliott and Dustan Taylor contributed to the medal count with a gold and silver in Men's Skeet.

Women's Interests



Get the best of NRA Women delivered to your inbox.